What is a training needs assessment?

A training needs assessment finds the gap between what people can do now and what the job needs, and who has that gap, before anyone books a course.

In shortA training needs assessment (TNA) is a structured look at performance problems and goals to decide whether training is the answer, what it should cover and who needs it. It usually works at three levels: the organization (which goals or problems matter), the task (what the job requires) and the individual (who is missing which skill). The result is a short list of specific gaps with the people attached, which keeps training budgets off people who do not need it and points out problems that training will not fix, such as broken equipment or unclear procedures.

The three levels

Three levels of a training needs assessment
Level Question Evidence to use
Organization Which result is off target? Error rates, complaints, safety incidents, turnover
Task What does the job require to hit it? Job description, procedures, top performers
Individual Who is missing which skill? Observation, skills checks, records by person

If the gap is not a skill, training will not close it. A cashier who knows the procedure but is pressed for time needs staffing, not a course. See employee skills assessment for ways to test individual skills.

Voided orders over 3 months, by server group6 new servers70%34 other servers30%Training 6 people instead of 40: $270 vs. $1,200
Sorting the problem by person showed that a small group of new hires caused most of it.

Worked example: voids at a restaurant group

120 voided orders a month

A restaurant group with 40 servers sees about 120 voided orders a month, each costing food and time. The first plan is a 2-hour refresher for all 40 servers.

A needs assessment pulls voids by server for 3 months. 6 servers account for 84 of the 120 voids, or 70 percent, and all 6 were hired in the last 90 days. Watching a few shifts shows the cause: new servers were never shown how to modify an order already sent to the kitchen, so they void and re-enter it.

All-staff training would cost 40 servers times 2 hours times $15, or $1,200, plus lost floor time. A 3-hour session for the 6 new servers costs 6 times 3 times $15, or $270, and the modify step is added to the onboarding checklist so the next hires learn it in week one. The root cause was an onboarding gap, not a skill gap across the whole team.

Mistakes that are specific to training needs assessments

Choosing between training and other fixes

The most useful output of a needs assessment is often a decision not to train. For each gap, ask three questions: does the person know how to do it, do they have what they need to do it (time, tools, staffing), and does anything stop them or reward them for doing it differently? Only a no to the first question is a training need.

Write down the other fixes as clearly as the training ones: a broken scanner to replace, a procedure to rewrite, a schedule that leaves no time for a closing task. Give each an owner and a date. A needs assessment that only produces a course list misses half of what it found.

Second example: closing checklists left unfinished

A retail chain finds that closing checklists are fully completed on only 58% of nights. The first idea is a refresher on closing duties for all closers.

The assessment shows closers know the steps. The problem is time: 2 closers cover a store scheduled for 3 on most weeknights. The chain adds a third closer for the last 90 minutes on its 4 busiest nights and keeps the refresher only for the 5 new closers. Completion rises to 91% in a month.

Sort by person before you buy anythingBefore approving any group training, sort the problem data by person, shift and hire date. If a small group accounts for most of the problem, the fix is usually targeted coaching or onboarding, not a course for everyone.

Questions people ask

What are the steps of a training needs assessment?

Define the result that is off target, describe what the job needs, find who has the gap, check that training is the right fix, then set the measure you will use afterward.

What is the difference between a skills gap and a training need?

A skills gap is the difference between current and required skills. A training need exists only when training is the right way to close it.

How often should you do a training needs assessment?

Many teams do a light one yearly with the budget and a focused one whenever a key measure moves the wrong way.

Who should be involved?

The manager who owns the result, a few people who do the job well, and whoever runs training.

What tools are used in a training needs assessment?

Performance data, observation, short skills checks, surveys of employees and managers, and records such as errors or incidents by person and shift.

How long does a training needs assessment take?

For a focused problem in a small business, a week or two. A company-wide assessment can take a month or more.

Related on EZTime

Related guides and tools

Reach every shift, not just the office

Announcements by location, department or role, and a company feed with surveys and read confirmations, so frontline staff see the same news.