Comparison guides for time and attendance

Vendor-neutral guides for choosing a time clock, a punch method or a full system, and for working out what it will really cost.

Start with the decision you are actually making

Most buying decisions in time and attendance come down to three questions, and these guides are organized around them. First, do you need only a clock, or a system that also applies pay rules and approvals? Second, how will employees punch in: on a wall terminal, a shared tablet, their own phone, or a tag at the entrance? Third, what will it cost once you include hardware, setup and the time managers spend fixing records?

The guides are vendor-neutral. They describe how each approach works, where it tends to fail, and which legal points to check, such as biometric consent rules or state requirements to keep time records for a set number of years. Where EZTime is relevant, we say so separately so you can tell the general advice from the product.

The guides

Time clock vs. time and attendance system

A time clock records punches. A time and attendance system also applies your rules: overtime thresholds, breaks, approvals and pay codes. Read this first if you are not sure which of the two you are shopping for.

Time clock app vs. biometric clock

Phone apps travel with the employee and can add a GPS stamp. Fingerprint or face terminals stay on the wall and stop one person clocking in for another. The guide also covers biometric privacy laws such as Illinois BIPA, which affect whether a fingerprint clock is a good idea at all.

NFC vs. GPS vs. biometric

Three ways to prove that someone was where they said they were. NFC tags are cheap and work indoors, GPS works anywhere with signal, and biometrics prove identity rather than place. A side-by-side table shows which fits which kind of site.

How to choose a time clock

A practical checklist: number of sites, field versus fixed staff, union or state record rules, payroll export and what happens when someone forgets to punch out.

What makes a good time clock

The features that matter after the first month of use, such as missed-punch handling and manager approvals, rather than the ones that look good in a demo.

Time and attendance system cost

Per-employee pricing, monthly minimums, hardware, setup fees and the hidden cost of payroll errors. It explains what moves the price up or down for a team of your size.

Paper, spreadsheets, apps and systems

A table comparing the four common approaches on setup effort, proof of time, corrections, scheduling and payroll prep, with the team size where each one usually stops working.

Switching from what you use today

If you already have a method and it is not working, this page covers why teams switch, a checklist for moving over, and how to run old and new side by side for one pay period.

A quick way to narrow it down

Whatever you choose, run it next to your current method for one full pay period and compare the totals before you switch over.

All comparison guides, by question

Clock or full system?

Which punch method?

What will it cost?

Setting it up

Want a second opinion?

Tell us how your team works and we will help you pick.