What Happens If You Don't
Track Employee Hours?

What federal law requires you to record, what happens in an audit or wage claim when records are missing, and a simple plan to fix gaps before they become expensive.
Manager calculating employee hours from time cards

The short answer

If you don’t keep accurate records of hours for non-exempt employees, you are out of compliance with the FLSA’s recordkeeping rules, and you lose your best defense in a wage claim. When an employer’s records are missing or unreliable, courts can accept the employee’s reasonable estimate of hours worked, and the employer must disprove it. Unpaid wages can be recovered for two years back (three if willful), usually doubled through liquidated damages, plus the employee’s attorney’s fees.

What the law requires you to record

Under 29 CFR 516.2, employers must keep these records for each non-exempt employee:

  • Full name, home address and, if under 19, date of birth
  • Sex and occupation
  • Day and time the workweek begins
  • Hours worked each workday and total hours each workweek
  • Regular hourly rate and basis of pay
  • Total straight-time earnings and overtime premium pay
  • Additions to and deductions from wages
  • Total wages paid each pay period, the pay date and the period covered

Keep payroll records at least three years and time cards at least two years (29 CFR 516.5 and 516.6). The Department of Labor lets you use any timekeeping method, as long as the records are complete and accurate.

What can go wrong

RiskWhat it means
Back wagesUnpaid straight time and overtime, generally for 2 years, or 3 if the violation was willful
Liquidated damagesAn equal additional amount, which can double what you owe
Attorney’s feesIn private lawsuits, the employer usually pays the employee’s legal fees if the employee wins
Burden shifts to youWithout reliable records, the employee’s reasonable estimate can stand (Anderson v. Mt. Clemens Pottery, 1946)
Collective actionsOne complaint can grow to cover a whole group of similar employees
State penaltiesMany states add their own penalties, waiting-time pay or longer look-back periods

Enforcement is active: the Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour Division recovered more than $259 million in back wages for nearly 177,000 workers in fiscal year 2025.

Hidden day-to-day costs

  • Overpayment: rounding up and estimated hours add up. Ten minutes a day for 20 employees at $18 per hour is about $1,320 a month.
  • Unplanned overtime: without weekly totals, you find overtime after it is owed.
  • Disputes: no record means your word against the employee’s.
  • Manager time: rebuilding hours from texts and memory every pay period.

Common situations that create risk

  • Paper timesheets filled in at the end of the week
  • Salaried pay for employees who don’t meet an exemption
  • Work before clock-in or after clock-out, such as opening tasks or answering messages
  • Unpaid meal breaks that are interrupted
  • Rounding that always favors the employer
  • Edits to timecards without notes or employee confirmation

See FLSA overtime rules and rounding rules.

How to fix it

  1. Classify each role correctly as exempt or non-exempt.
  2. Define your workweek in writing.
  3. Choose a clock-in method for each site: app, kiosk or NFC. See best time clock for 2027.
  4. Record meal breaks and set alerts for state rules.
  5. Require notes and employee confirmation for every edit.
  6. Approve hours weekly and keep records for the required periods.

EZTime keeps a full audit trail and lets employees sign attendance reports digitally. See time and attendance software.

Frequently asked questions

Not having a device isn’t illegal, but failing to keep accurate records of hours worked for non-exempt employees violates the FLSA recordkeeping rules.

Yes. They can claim unpaid wages and overtime, and without your records a court can rely on their reasonable estimate of hours worked.

Under the FLSA, generally two years, or three years for willful violations. Some states allow longer.

For exempt employees, hour records aren’t required federally. Salaried employees who don’t meet an exemption are non-exempt, and you must track their hours.

Typically payroll records, time records showing daily and weekly hours, pay rates and records of deductions for the period under review.

Related guides

Protect your business from wage claims

Policies and records that hold up.

FLSA overtime rules

How overtime is calculated, with examples.

Time clock rounding rules

When rounding is allowed and when it is risky.

Time clock vs. attendance system

What a full system adds to a simple clock.

Free timesheet template

A starting point if you track hours manually today.

This page is general information about U.S. federal rules and isn’t legal advice. State laws can be stricter; consult an employment attorney about your situation.

Keep records that hold up

Join more than 10,000 businesses that manage their teams with EZTime. 14-day trial, no credit card required.