What is timesheet approval?

Timesheet approval is the step where a manager confirms an employee’s recorded hours are correct before payroll uses them. It is where missed punches, overtime and break problems are caught.

In shortTimesheet approval is the review and sign-off of recorded working time for a pay period, usually by the employee’s manager and sometimes by the employee too. It confirms that clock-ins, clock-outs, breaks and overtime are accurate, and that any corrections are explained. Approval does not change the employer’s duty to pay for all time actually worked, and federal rules require keeping the records: payroll records for at least 3 years and basic time cards for at least 2.

What approval should check

  1. Missing punches. A clock-in with no clock-out, or the reverse.
  2. Edits. Any change to a recorded time should have a reason and the name of the person who made it.
  3. Overtime. Hours over 40 in a workweek, and daily overtime where state law requires it. Unapproved overtime still has to be paid; approval is about knowing, not about deciding whether to pay.
  4. Breaks. Missed or short meal breaks where state law requires them.
  5. Job or location tags. Hours split between sites or roles, if they affect pay rates or billing.
18 timesheets, 6 exceptionsok!okok!okok!okok!okok!okok!okReview the 6 flagged sheets, approve the 12 clean ones together.
Exception-first approval: the manager opens only the timesheets with missing punches, long shifts or missed breaks.

Who signs, and what the signature means

A manager’s approval says the hours match what the manager knows. An employee’s sign-off says the employee agrees the hours are complete. Many employers use both: the employee confirms, then the manager approves. EZTime sends employees a monthly attendance report they can sign digitally, and timecard corrections go through a missed-punch request that the manager approves, with an audit trail of who changed what.

Keep the approved records. Under 29 CFR 516.5, payroll records are kept for at least 3 years, and under 29 CFR 516.6, basic time cards for at least 2 years. Many states require longer.

Worked example: one manager, 18 timesheets, Monday morning

A biweekly approval in 20 minutes

A restaurant manager approves 18 timesheets every other Monday by noon. She starts with the exceptions: 3 missing clock-outs, 2 shifts over 10 hours and 1 missed meal break. The 3 missing clock-outs all have missed-punch requests from the employees with times that match the closing checklist, so she approves them. The 2 long shifts were a catering event; she approves them and notes the event.

The missed meal break was a busy Saturday. In her state that triggers a premium, so she flags it for payroll instead of editing the break in. The other 12 timesheets have no exceptions. Total time: about 20 minutes, because she reviewed the 6 exceptions, not 18 timesheets line by line.

Mistakes that are specific to timesheet approval

Setting an approval calendar

Approval works when everyone knows the deadline. Set a fixed time for each step in the pay period: employees fix missed punches by the end of the last day, managers approve by a set hour the next working day, and payroll closes after that. Publish the calendar for the year, with earlier deadlines in holiday weeks.

Name a backup approver for every manager. When a manager is on vacation or out sick, the backup approves, so no timesheet waits and nobody’s pay is late because one person was away.

A biweekly approval calendar
Step Deadline Who
Missed-punch requests submitted Sunday, end of the period Employees
Exceptions reviewed and approved Monday, 12:00 p.m. Manager or backup
Payroll export Monday, 3:00 p.m. Payroll

Second example: the manager on vacation

A clinic’s office manager is on vacation on the Monday that timesheets are due. In the past, payroll waited for her return, and two hourly employees with overtime were paid late.

The clinic names the lead nurse as backup approver. The next time the office manager is away, the lead nurse reviews the 4 exceptions and approves on time, and the original punches and her approval are both kept in the audit trail.

Approve exceptions, not rowsAsk for a list of only the timesheets with a problem: missing punches, overtime, missed breaks, edits. If that list is empty, approval is one click. If it is long, you have found what to fix in next week’s schedule.

Questions people ask

Who should approve timesheets?

Usually the direct manager or shift lead who knows when the person worked. In larger teams, payroll or HR does a second check of exceptions.

Do employees have to sign their timesheets?

Federal law does not require an employee signature, but many employers ask for one because it confirms the hours are complete and reduces later disputes. Some states and union contracts have their own rules.

Can a manager refuse to approve overtime that was worked?

The manager can address the employee’s failure to get permission, but the hours worked still have to be paid.

How long must approved timesheets be kept?

Federal rules require payroll records for at least 3 years and basic time cards for at least 2 years. Check your state, which may require longer.

What happens if a manager does not approve timesheets on time?

Pay must still go out on the regular payday. A backup approver or payroll should review the exceptions so nobody is paid late.

Can approved timesheets be changed later?

Yes, if an error is found. Keep the original record, record the correction with a reason and approver, and pay any difference.

Related on EZTime

Related guides and tools

Accurate hours from the first punch

Employees clock in by mobile GPS, web, kiosk or NFC, with geofencing, break alerts and missed-punch requests that keep an audit trail.

Disclaimer: This explanation of timesheet approval is general information, not legal, payroll or tax advice; rules differ by state and city and change over time, and the examples are fictional.