What are employee rewards?

Employee rewards are the extra things a business gives in return for good work or milestones: money, time off, perks or opportunities. How a reward is promised decides whether it affects overtime pay.

In shortEmployee rewards are tangible returns for performance, behavior or milestones, beyond base pay. They range from cash bonuses and extra paid time off to meals, merchandise, preferred shifts, training opportunities and promotions. They overlap with recognition, which is about acknowledgment, and incentives, which are announced in advance to drive a result. For hourly employees, one federal wage rule shapes how cash rewards work. A bonus is discretionary, and can be left out of the overtime regular rate, only if the employer keeps discretion over both whether to pay it and how much until close to the end of the period, with no prior promise. A bonus announced in advance to get people to work more steadily, faster, more efficiently or to stay is not discretionary and must be included in the regular rate, whatever it is called. Cash and many non-cash rewards can also be taxable wages, so check with payroll before you start.

Types of rewards

Common employee rewards
Reward Example Watch out for
Spot bonus $100 after an exceptional week, decided afterwards Becomes nondiscretionary if promised in advance
Extra paid time off A paid afternoon off Track it like other PTO
Preferred shifts First pick of next month’s schedule Apply the same rule to everyone
Development Paid certification course Training time may be hours worked
Meals and merchandise Team lunch, branded jacket Tax treatment varies; ask payroll
Same $150, different overtime resultDecided afterwardsNot promisedAmount chosen laterDiscretionaryNot in regular ratePromised in advance“Clean 15 rooms a day”Announced to drive speedNondiscretionaryAdds $9.78 overtime
When and how a bonus is promised decides whether it changes overtime pay.

Worked example: two bonuses that look the same

Decided afterwards vs. promised in advance

A hotel’s housekeeping manager gives three housekeepers a $150 bonus each after a week when a large group checked in early and they turned every room in time. Nobody was told in advance; the manager decided after seeing the results. This is a discretionary bonus and does not go into the regular rate.

The next month, the hotel announces: “Anyone who cleans 15 or more rooms a shift every day this week gets $150.” Because it was promised in advance to get people to work faster, it is nondiscretionary. One housekeeper who earned it worked 46 hours at $17 an hour. The $150 is spread over the 46 hours, about $3.26 an hour, raising her regular rate to $20.26. She is owed an extra half of $3.26 for each of her 6 overtime hours, about $9.78.

Payroll adds the $9.78. The hotel now labels every cash reward in payroll by type, so the overtime math is done automatically.

Mistakes that are specific to employee rewards

Keeping rewards fair and consistent

Rewards lose their value when people think they go to favorites. Write down what each type of reward is for, who can give it and any limits per person, and keep a simple log of who received what. Review the log each quarter by shift and location to check that rewards reach every part of the team.

Mix big and small. A few larger rewards for real milestones, and many small, quick ones for good work this week, work better than one annual prize. The small ones keep the habit of noticing going; the large ones show that sustained effort counts.

Second example: a reward log that showed a gap

A hotel’s reward log for six months shows 42 spot rewards: 31 to front desk staff, 9 to housekeeping and 2 to the overnight team, although housekeeping is the largest department.

Managers realize they reward what they see, and they rarely see housekeeping at work. Supervisors start asking housekeeping leads for nominations each week. In the next quarter, rewards are spread more evenly, and housekeeping’s survey score for “my work is noticed” rises.

Decide the reward after the result, not beforeIf you want a cash reward to stay out of overtime calculations, decide both whether and how much after the work is done, and do not announce it beforehand. If you want to motivate in advance, call it an incentive and include it in the regular rate.

Questions people ask

What are examples of employee rewards?

Spot bonuses, extra paid time off, preferred shifts, paid training, team meals and merchandise.

Do bonuses count toward overtime?

Nondiscretionary bonuses, such as those announced in advance to encourage performance or attendance, must be included in the regular rate. Truly discretionary bonuses are not.

What is the difference between rewards and recognition?

Recognition is acknowledgment, such as thanks or praise. Rewards are tangible, such as money, time off or opportunities.

Are employee rewards taxable?

Cash rewards are taxable wages, and many non-cash rewards are too. Ask your payroll provider about specific items.

What are low-cost employee rewards?

Extra paid time off, first pick of shifts, a meal during the shift, a paid course, or a specific thank-you from a senior manager.

How often should employees be rewarded?

Small rewards and recognition can be frequent, even weekly. Larger rewards work best for clear milestones.

Related on EZTime

You may also need

Reach every shift, not just the office

Announcements by location, department or role, and a company feed with surveys and read confirmations, so frontline staff see the same news.

Disclaimer: What you read here about employee rewards is general information, not legal, payroll or tax advice, so confirm the current rule where you operate; the examples are fictional.