Common misconceptions about overtime, salaried staff, at-will employment, contractors, breaks, pay discussions, comp time and final pay, and what federal law actually says, with links to the details.
Most small business owners learn HR from experience, previous employers and conversations with other owners. Rules that were true somewhere once, or that apply in one state but not another, get passed on as general truths. The result is a set of confident beliefs that can lead to wage claims, penalties or lawsuits. Here are the most common ones. Each is stated under federal law; your state may add rules, so treat this as a starting point, not the final word.
EZTime digital HR forms let you send, sign and file employee documents online.
Reality: paying a salary does not by itself make an employee exempt from overtime. Generally the employee must also earn at least the minimum salary level and perform duties that meet an exemption test, such as executive, administrative or professional duties. A salaried shift supervisor who mostly does the same work as their team may be non-exempt. See exempt vs. non-exempt employees.
Reality: at-will employment lets employers end employment for any lawful reason, but not for illegal ones, such as discrimination, retaliation for complaints or for using protected leave. Contracts and policies can also limit at-will termination, and Montana generally requires good cause after a probationary period. See at-will employment exceptions.
Reality: classification depends on the actual working relationship, not the tax form or what both sides agree to call it. Workers whose schedules, methods and tasks you control are often employees, and some states use strict tests. See independent contractor vs. employee.
Reality: under the National Labor Relations Act, most non-supervisory private-sector employees have the right to discuss wages and working conditions with each other, whether or not there is a union. Many states also have pay transparency laws. Policies banning pay discussions can be unlawful.
Reality: federal law does not require breaks for adults, but if you offer short rest breaks, usually about 5 to 20 minutes, they are generally counted as paid work time. Meal periods of 30 minutes or more can be unpaid if the employee is completely relieved of duty. Several states require meal or rest breaks. See California meal and rest break rules for a strict example and break tracking.
Reality: private-sector employers generally cannot give time off later instead of paying overtime under federal law. Comp time is mainly available to public employers. Adjusting hours within the same workweek to avoid overtime is different and generally allowed. See compensatory time.
Reality: if you know or should know that a non-exempt employee is working, including before clocking in, after clocking out or answering messages at home, the time must be paid, even if you did not authorize it. You can discipline employees for unauthorized overtime, but you must still pay for it. See off-the-clock work.
Reality: some federal laws apply only above certain sizes, such as Title VII at 15 employees and FMLA at 50. But wage and hour laws cover many small businesses, and state and city laws often apply to employers with just one employee. Do not assume your size makes you exempt. See our state labor law pages.
Reality: deductions for things like uniforms, shortages, damage or unreturned equipment are restricted by federal minimum wage rules and often by state law, which may require written authorization or ban some deductions entirely. Final paychecks also have state deadlines, some as short as the day of termination. See final paycheck rules.
Reality: it depends on the state and your policy. Some states require payout of earned vacation; many do not, unless your policy or practice promises it. Write a clear policy. See PTO policy for small business.
Reality: if a candidate performs productive work during a trial shift, that is generally work time that must be paid. Unpaid internships in the private sector are allowed only in limited circumstances, generally where the intern, not the business, is the primary beneficiary.
Reality: no federal law prohibits giving references. Many employers limit references to dates and title to reduce risk, and some states give employers protection for truthful references. Stick to facts and follow a consistent policy. See our employment verification letter guide and reference letter template.
Some myths can be settled with one official sentence. Here are three:
If you keep a short list of rules like these where managers can see it, you prevent the myths from spreading in the first place. Add a line for each new myth you hear and the source that answers it.
Myth check complete.
EZTime helps with the record-keeping side: accurate clock-ins and breaks, labor rule alerts, timecard corrections with an audit trail and signed policy acknowledgments. See labor law compliance.
Salaried employees are entitled to overtime unless they meet an exemption’s salary and duties tests. A salary alone does not make someone exempt.
Generally no for non-supervisory private-sector employees. The National Labor Relations Act protects their right to discuss wages and working conditions, and many states have pay transparency laws.
Federal law does not require meal or rest breaks for adults, but short breaks you provide are generally paid, and several states require meal or rest breaks.
Generally no. Under federal law, private-sector employers must pay overtime for hours over 40 in a workweek rather than giving time off later.
If the candidate does productive work, it is generally work time that must be paid. Treat trial shifts as paid work.
For exempt employees, only in limited situations. For example, the DOL lists deducting a day’s pay because the employer closed for bad weather as an improper deduction. Improper deductions can put the exemption itself at risk. Non-exempt salaried employees are paid for hours worked, so different rules apply.
Not by choice alone. Whether someone is a contractor depends on the actual working relationship, such as control and economic dependence, not on cost or what the contract says. Misclassification can lead to back wages, back taxes and penalties.
Accurate time records settle most pay questions. EZTime keeps clock-ins, breaks and corrections with an audit trail, so you can answer with facts.