How to reduce overtime costs

Why overtime gets expensive

Overtime is not always a problem. Some busy weeks truly need extra hours, and many teams rely on a bit of it. The trouble starts when overtime becomes the default way of covering gaps. Extra hours are usually paid at a higher rate, and tired employees make more mistakes, miss more shifts and are more likely to leave. Depending on where you operate, overtime rules also add complexity, so every unplanned hour carries risk as well as cost.

EZTime labor rule alerts flag overtime and missed rest periods before payroll.

Because the premium applies to each hour, a small habit can add up. If three employees each work four extra hours a week, that is twelve premium hours every week, or more than six hundred hours a year. Understanding that scale is the first step toward deciding whether it is worth tackling.

Step 1: Find where it comes from

Before changing anything, look at the last eight to twelve weeks of data. Group overtime by employee, by day of the week, by location and by reason. You are looking for patterns rather than blame.

• The same two people always work extra, which suggests uneven scheduling.
• Overtime spikes on one weekday, which suggests a staffing gap on that day.
• Overtime appears right after shift end, which suggests late handoffs or unfinished tasks.
• Overtime clusters at month end, which suggests a workload peak you can plan for.

Write the top two causes down. Fixing two things well beats tinkering with ten.

Step 2: Schedule to demand

Many teams build next week’s schedule by copying last week’s. That works until demand changes. Instead, estimate the hours you need per day using sales, appointments, tickets or job volume, then place people against it. Leave a small buffer for the unexpected rather than relying on the same few people to stretch.

Publish the schedule early so employees can plan and swap. A predictable schedule also reduces last-minute fixes, and last-minute fixes are where overtime tends to hide.

Step 3: Balance hours across the team

If some employees are close to full-time while others have spare hours, shifting a few shifts can remove overtime entirely. Look at your part-time and flexible staff first, and check availability before assigning.

In this example, total hours are the same, but nobody is over forty. The difference is only in who covers which shift.

Step 4: Add approval rules and alerts

Unapproved overtime is the easiest kind to prevent. Ask employees to request extra time before they work it, and give managers a simple way to approve or decline. Then add alerts so you hear about it early, not on payroll day.

• Alert a manager when an employee reaches 80 percent of the weekly threshold.
• Show a running total on the manager’s dashboard.
• Flag clock-ins that happen well before a scheduled shift.
• Review exceptions weekly, not monthly.

A time and attendance system such as EZTime can show hours as they build up, so a manager can send someone home an hour early on Thursday instead of discovering a problem on Monday.

Step 5: Fix handoffs and workflow

Sometimes overtime is simply work that does not finish in time. Look at what happens in the last hour of a shift. If the same task is always left, consider moving it earlier, splitting it across two people or adjusting the shift overlap so the next person can pick up. Even a fifteen minute overlap between shifts can remove daily overtime for a whole team.

Step 6: Talk to your team

Employees often know exactly why overtime happens. Ask what slows them down, which shifts feel short-staffed and where they would like more or fewer hours. Be careful to explain that the goal is a fairer, more predictable schedule, not cutting pay. People are far more likely to help when they understand the reason.

Also recognize that some employees want overtime. Be open about how extra hours are offered, and offer them fairly. A clear, written policy avoids the impression of favorites.

Step 7: Track the result

Pick two numbers: overtime hours per week and overtime as a share of total hours. Measure them before you change anything, and again every month. Share the trend with managers. If the numbers move in the right direction, keep the new habits. If not, go back to step one and look at the data again.

Keep in mind that rules on overtime differ by location, role and contract, so confirm what applies to you with a qualified professional before changing pay practices.

Weekly versus daily overtime: the same week, two answers

Federal law under the Fair Labor Standards Act counts overtime after 40 hours in a workweek. A few states also count it by the day. California is the best known: time and a half after 8 hours in a workday, double time after 12, plus rules for a seventh consecutive day. The same schedule can cost very different amounts:

Under the daily rule, each day has 8 regular hours and 2 overtime hours: 32 x $20.00 plus 8 x $30.00. Before you move people to longer, fewer days to save on overtime, check the rules in each state where you operate. California allows alternative workweek schedules only through a formal process with a secret ballot vote of the affected employees.

Check classification before you count

Overtime rules apply to non-exempt employees. To be exempt under the federal executive, administrative or professional exemptions, an employee generally must be paid a salary of at least $684 a week and meet a duties test. A 2024 DOL rule that would have raised the threshold was struck down by a federal court, so check the current figure. Several states, including California, New York and Washington, set higher thresholds.

Paying someone a salary does not by itself make them exempt. A salaried shift supervisor who spends most of the day doing the same work as the team may be owed overtime. When reducing overtime, look at classification once, so you are not cutting hours that were never counted.

Frequently asked questions

Where to go next