What is disability discrimination at work?

Disability discrimination is treating a qualified employee or applicant worse because of a disability, or failing to make a reasonable accommodation the law requires. Most cases turn on how the employer handled a request, not on bad intent.

In shortUnder the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), employers with 15 or more employees for each working day in 20 or more calendar weeks in the current or preceding year may not discriminate against a qualified individual because of disability. The law also counts as discrimination not making reasonable accommodations to the known physical or mental limitations of a qualified employee or applicant, unless the accommodation would impose an undue hardship, defined as an action requiring significant difficulty or expense. Many states have their own disability laws, some covering smaller employers.

The forms it takes

Common forms of disability discrimination
Form What it looks like on the job
Disparate treatment Passing over a qualified worker for a promotion because of a diagnosis
Failure to accommodate Refusing a schedule change or a stool without looking at whether it is workable
Screening out A job requirement that excludes people with disabilities and is not job related
Harassment Jokes or comments about a condition that a supervisor lets continue

The common thread is a decision about a person based on a condition rather than on whether they can do the essential functions of the job, with or without an accommodation. A clear job description that lists essential functions is often the first document anyone looks at when a decision is questioned.

From request to documented decisionEmployeeasksTalk aboutthe needWeighoptionsDecide anddocumentCheck in after a few weeks
A flat no skips every box in the middle. That is where most failures to accommodate start.

Worked example: a request for short breaks

A warehouse picker with diabetes

A picker on a 10-hour shift tells her lead that she needs to check her blood sugar and eat something small about every 2 hours. The current schedule has one 30-minute meal and no other breaks. The lead’s first answer is that breaks are fixed for everyone.

HR steps in, meets with her, and asks what she needs, which is a 5-minute pause about every 2 hours. The team looks at cost: 3 extra 5-minute pauses a shift is 15 minutes, and since short breaks are paid under federal rules, that is about $5 a shift at $20 an hour. Pick targets are adjusted by 15 minutes. That is not significant difficulty or expense for a warehouse with 140 employees. The change is written down, dated, and her lead is told what changed, not why.

Had the lead’s first answer stood, the company would have refused an accommodation with no assessment at all, which is the kind of decision that is hard to defend later.

How to respond to an accommodation request

  1. Treat any request that links a work change to a medical condition as a request, even if the word accommodation is never used.
  2. Talk with the employee about the limitation and what would help. This back and forth is often called the interactive process.
  3. Ask for medical information only when the disability or need is not obvious, and keep it in a separate confidential file.
  4. Consider options, including the one the employee suggests. You can choose among effective options.
  5. Document the decision and the reasons, and check in after a few weeks to see if it works.

Mistakes that are specific to disability discrimination

Medical information and documentation

When a disability or the need for an accommodation is not obvious, an employer can ask for reasonable documentation, limited to what is needed to establish the disability and the need. It should not ask for complete medical records.

Any medical information the employer receives must be kept confidential and stored separately from the general personnel file. Supervisors can be told about necessary restrictions and accommodations, not the diagnosis. A condition can be a disability even if it is temporary, if it substantially limits a major life activity.

Second example: an accommodation with a time limit

A grocery cashier recovering from a serious back injury asks to sit on a stool for her next four months of shifts. Her provider’s note confirms the limitation and the expected length.

The store does not need her full records. It keeps the note in the confidential medical file, tells her supervisor only that she may use a stool at the register until a set review date, and schedules her on registers where a stool fits. At the review date, the store and the cashier talk again about whether she still needs it.

Train the person who hears it firstMost accommodation requests are first said out loud to a shift lead, not written to HR. One sentence in lead training, “if someone links a work change to a health issue, say you will get back to them and tell HR the same day”, prevents the most common failure.

Questions people ask

Which employers does the ADA cover?

Employers with 15 or more employees for each working day in 20 or more calendar weeks in the current or preceding calendar year. State laws may cover smaller employers.

What is an undue hardship?

An action requiring significant difficulty or expense, judged by factors such as the cost of the accommodation and the employer’s size and resources.

How long does an employee have to file a charge with the EEOC?

Generally 180 calendar days from the discrimination, extended to 300 days where a state or local agency enforces a law against the same kind of discrimination.

Does an employee have to use the word accommodation?

No. A request in plain words that connects a needed change at work to a medical condition is usually enough to start the process.

Can an employer ask for medical documentation for an accommodation?

Yes, when the disability or need is not obvious, limited to what is needed to establish the disability and the need for the accommodation.

Does the ADA cover temporary conditions?

It can. A temporary condition can be a disability if it is severe enough to substantially limit a major life activity.

Related on EZTime

Keep reading

Keep HR paperwork and updates in one place

Digital HR forms, e-signatures and a digital employee file with expiry reminders, plus announcements by location, department or role.

Disclaimer: What you read here about disability discrimination is general information, not legal, payroll or tax advice, so confirm the current rule where you operate; the examples are fictional.