Employment background checks

Background checks can protect your customers and team, but they come with strict rules. Here is how to run them lawfully and fairly.

In shortAn employment background check is a review of a candidate’s history, such as criminal records, identity, employment and education, driving record, or professional licenses, to inform a hiring decision. When employers use a background check company, the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act requires a standalone written disclosure, the candidate’s written authorization, and a two-step adverse action process before rejecting someone based on the report. Many states and cities add fair chance (ban-the-box) rules on when and how criminal history can be considered.

Common types of background checks

Types of employment screening
Check What it covers Typical use
Identity and SSN trace Confirms identity and finds past addresses Starting point for other searches
Criminal records County, state and federal court records; sex offender registries Many roles, especially those with access to customers, homes or vulnerable people
Motor vehicle record Driving history, license status Drivers and roles using company vehicles
Employment verification Dates and titles with past employers Confirming experience
Education verification Degrees and attendance Roles requiring specific education
Professional license License status and discipline Nurses, electricians, plumbers, security guards
Credit report Credit history Limited roles; restricted in many states
Drug testing Substance use Safety-sensitive and federally regulated roles; state laws vary
Healthcare sanctions Exclusion lists for federal health programs Healthcare employers

Only run checks that relate to the job. A cashier and a delivery driver need different screening.

The Fair Credit Reporting Act steps

When you use a consumer reporting agency (a background check company), the FCRA generally requires:

  1. Disclosure. Give the candidate a clear written disclosure that you may obtain a background report, in a document that consists solely of the disclosure.
  2. Authorization. Get the candidate’s written permission before ordering the report.
  3. Certification. Certify to the background check company that you will follow the FCRA and anti-discrimination laws.
  4. Pre-adverse action notice. If you may reject the candidate based on the report, first send a notice with a copy of the report and the document “A Summary of Your Rights Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act.”
  5. Waiting period. Give the candidate a reasonable opportunity to respond or dispute errors before you decide.
  6. Adverse action notice. If you make a final decision not to hire, send a notice that includes the background company’s contact information, a statement that the company did not make the decision, and the candidate’s right to dispute and to get a free copy of the report.

Some states, such as California and New York, have additional disclosure and notice requirements. Many background check providers supply compliant forms, but you remain responsible.

Fair chance and ban-the-box laws

Many states, cities and counties have fair chance laws that limit when employers can ask about criminal history, often not until after a conditional job offer, and require an individualized assessment before rejecting a candidate because of a conviction. Some require specific notices and a waiting period. Federal agencies and federal contractors are covered by the Fair Chance to Compete for Jobs Act. Check the rules everywhere you hire.

Even where no specific law applies, the EEOC has issued guidance that blanket exclusions of anyone with a criminal record may have a disparate impact on protected groups. A common approach is to consider the nature and seriousness of the offense, the time that has passed and the nature of the job.

What background reports may include

Credit checks: proceed carefully

Several states and cities restrict employers from using credit history in hiring except for specific jobs, such as those handling significant money or sensitive financial information. Even where allowed, credit checks are subject to the FCRA. Use them only where clearly job-related.

Drug testing

Drug testing rules depend heavily on state law and industry. Employers regulated by the US Department of Transportation, such as those with commercial drivers, must follow federal testing rules. Many states regulate when testing can occur, which methods are allowed and how cannabis use is treated, including some laws protecting off-duty cannabis use. Have a written policy reviewed by counsel.

Step-by-step: a compliant process

  1. Decide which checks each role needs, based on duties.
  2. Write a background check policy and apply it consistently.
  3. Choose a reputable background check provider.
  4. Follow fair chance timing rules; in many places, run criminal checks only after a conditional offer.
  5. Give the standalone disclosure and get written authorization.
  6. Review results using job-related criteria and an individualized assessment.
  7. Follow the pre-adverse and adverse action steps if you may reject a candidate.
  8. Keep reports confidential and store them separately from personnel files; dispose of them securely when no longer needed.

Background checks in shift-based industries

Common screening by industry
Industry Typical checks
Home care and healthcare Criminal records, license verification, healthcare sanctions lists, state-required checks for caregivers
Security State security guard licensing usually includes fingerprint-based checks
Cleaning and field service Criminal records for in-home work; motor vehicle records for drivers
Restaurants and retail Often limited; sometimes criminal checks for cash handling or management roles
Transportation and delivery Motor vehicle records; DOT drug and alcohol testing for covered drivers

Some state laws require specific checks for jobs involving children, older adults or people with disabilities. See our home care agencies page for how eztime supports caregiving teams.

Turnaround time and candidate experience

Record-keeping and privacy

Background reports contain sensitive personal information. Store them securely with limited access, separate from general personnel files. Federal rules require proper disposal of consumer report information when you no longer need it, such as shredding paper or securely deleting files. Keep hiring records for the period federal and state laws require. Our personnel file guide explains what goes where, and the digital employee file can help with access controls.

Frequently asked questions

Do employers need permission to run a background check?

When using a background check company, yes. The FCRA requires a standalone written disclosure and the candidate’s written authorization before the report is ordered.

What is an adverse action notice?

A notice an employer must send under the FCRA after deciding not to hire someone based in whole or part on a background report. It must be preceded by a pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and a summary of rights.

How far back do background checks go?

Under the FCRA, most negative information other than criminal convictions generally cannot be reported after seven years for jobs below a certain salary level. Convictions are not limited federally, but some states restrict how far back they can be reported.

What is ban the box?

Fair chance laws, often called ban-the-box laws, limit when employers can ask about criminal history, often not until after a conditional offer, and may require an individualized assessment before rejecting a candidate.

Can I refuse to hire someone because of a criminal record?

It depends on the offense, the job, the time that has passed and state and local laws. Blanket bans can create discrimination risk. Use an individualized, job-related assessment and follow fair chance procedures.

Can employers check credit history?

In many places, yes, with FCRA compliance, but several states and cities restrict credit checks to specific types of jobs.

Do I need to run background checks on every employee?

No federal law requires background checks for most private-sector jobs, but some states and industries require them for certain roles, such as caregivers, security guards and commercial drivers. If you screen, apply your policy consistently to all candidates for the same role.

Where to go next

Useful next steps

Signed copies in the employee file

Employees can fill in and sign forms like this in the EZTime app, and the signed copy lands in their digital employee file.

Disclaimer: This guide is general information only and is not legal advice. Background check, fair chance, credit check and drug testing laws vary by state and locality and change over time. Consult a qualified employment attorney before screening candidates.